Landowner reviewing an aerial property image on a truck tailgate beside a trail camera and pen.

Michigan Earn A Second Buck: 5 Pilot Counties & 2027 Rules

14 Minutes

If you hunt Barry, Hillsdale, Ingham, Kalamazoo, or Lapeer County, the 2027–28 deer season brings something new to those five Lower Peninsula counties: Michigan’s earn-a-second-buck (EASB) pilot. The deal is simple enough. Buy the earn-a-second-buck license package ($40 for residents and nonresidents; $28 for senior residents), harvest and report an antlerless deer in a pilot county, and you’re eligible for a bonus buck tag. That tag runs $20 for residents and $170 for nonresidents, and it’s good on a buck carrying at least four points on one side. Wildlife Conservation Order (WCO) Amendment No. 7 authorizes the five-year pilot. The pilot’s rules take effect March 1, 2027, it runs until it sunsets on January 2, 2032, and the DNR will measure it against five paired control counties.

Key takeaways

  • Not live yet: earn-a-second-buck starts with the 2027–28 season. Nobody can earn a second buck in 2026.
  • Pilot counties: Barry, Hillsdale, Ingham, Kalamazoo and Lapeer, each paired with a control county (Allegan, Lenawee, Isabella, Washtenaw, Livingston) that gets no second buck.
  • How it works: buy the EASB package ($40 resident and nonresident, $28 senior), harvest and report an antlerless deer in a pilot county, then buy the bonus buck tag ($20 resident, $170 nonresident) for a buck with at least four points on one side.
  • Fees: approved by the NRC in August 2026. Confirm them when the DNR publishes 2027 license fees.
  • Land: in the pilot counties, habitat that produces antlerless harvest becomes part of what a buyer is paying for.

At Michigan Whitetail Properties, we’ve walked this ground since 1995, and the practical effect on land starts well before 2027: a property that reliably produces antlerless harvest is about to become a property that can produce two bucks.

That’s not a small distinction if you own ground in Hillsdale County or you’re shopping for it. Grab a coffee. We’re going to walk through exactly what this program does, how the mechanism works, and, plainly, what it does to the value of the dirt under your boots.

What the Earn-a-Second-Buck Pilot Actually Is

Two white-tailed bucks standing beside a harvested cornfield with autumn woods behind themUnder the earn-a-second-buck pilot, if you take an antlerless deer in one of five designated counties, you can buy a second tag for a buck with at least four points on one side. It does not start this fall. The opportunity begins with the 2027-28 season, not 2026.

This is the part that tangles up a lot of hunters. The Natural Resources Commission first approved the pilot concept on May 13, 2026. Its final approval was of WCO Amendment No. 7, issued on August 12, 2026. The order sets the EASB rules to take effect March 1, 2027, the start of the 2027 license year. Approval and a hunter actually earning a second buck are two different things. No one is shooting a bonus buck this fall under this program. Nobody. The five pilot counties don’t open for EASB until next year’s season.

We’re being blunt about that because the timeline has already been muddled in plenty of hunting-forum threads. If you’re evaluating a property this fall based on an assumption that EASB is live right now, you’re working from bad information.

Why does a lead time of roughly a year matter to anyone besides a hunter marking a calendar? Because land doesn’t wait for the season to open before its value starts moving. Buyers and sellers who understand the mechanism now (who needs to report harvest, and where) are already positioning ahead of a market that hasn’t fully priced it in. That’s the entire second half of this article.

The Five Pilot Counties and Their Five Control Counties

Aerial view of autumn farmland with harvested fields, standing corn, woodlots and a rural road past a white barnThe DNR didn’t pick five counties at random and call it science. Each pilot county is paired with a control county chosen for comparable habitat, deer density, and hunting pressure. The paired design is what lets researchers isolate the pilot’s actual effect from ordinary year-to-year variation.

Pilot County Paired Control County
Barry Allegan
Hillsdale Lenawee
Ingham Isabella
Kalamazoo Washtenaw
Lapeer Livingston

If your ground sits in one of the five control counties, nothing changes for you at the tag counter. You won’t have earn-a-second-buck eligibility in 2027. Your county’s harvest data still matters, though. The DNR leans on it as the baseline to see whether the pilot counties really moved the needle on antlerless harvest and deer density, or whether the change was just noise.

How the Mechanism Works, Step by Step

It isn’t complicated. The order you do things in is what counts. If you skip a step, the bonus tag never opens up for you.

  1. At the license counter in 2027, pick the earn-a-second-buck package, which costs $40 for residents and nonresidents and $28 for senior residents. It includes a single deer license and a universal antlerless license.
  2. Harvest an antlerless deer, but it has to happen inside one of the five pilot counties. An antlerless deer taken in Lenawee doesn’t count toward Hillsdale eligibility.
  3. Report that antlerless harvest to the DNR. Mandatory, not optional.
  4. Once reported, you’re eligible to buy the bonus buck tag as a separate, second purchase: $20 for a Michigan resident (including seniors), $170 for a nonresident.
  5. The bonus tag is valid on a buck with at least four points on one side, and only within the pilot area.

    What doesn’t qualify: an antlerless harvest outside the five pilot counties, and any harvest that never gets reported. Both are dead ends.

 

Hunter in camouflage holding a smartphone with a reporting form beside a pickup tailgate with binoculars, a thermos and an antlerThe doe comes first. Always. Every hunter chasing a second Hillsdale County buck in 2027 starts the same way: by putting an antlerless deer on the ground and reporting it.

Walk through a real scenario. Say you hold ground in Barry County, you’ve bought the earn-a-second-buck package, and you take an antlerless deer opening week of archery season. You report it through the same harvest reporting system Michigan hunters already use for every deer they tag. From that point forward, you can purchase the bonus tag ($20 for a resident, $170 for a nonresident) and hunt a second buck anywhere on that Barry County property, provided it carries at least four points on one side. Nothing about your first buck tag changes. The bonus tag is additive: it is a second buck tag on top of the tags in your $40 package.

Why the DNR Built It This Way

This program was never about handing out more opportunity for its own sake. Read between the lines of the NRC’s own framing and the real objectives are density management and disease surveillance, specifically giving the department a tool to pull down antlerless numbers in a five-county block of the southern Lower Peninsula where chronic wasting disease has been an ongoing concern.

The five-year window matters too. A single season of data tells you almost nothing about deer population trends. With five years of data and five paired control counties, the DNR gets something closer to a real experiment. It can compare before and after, and treatment against control, instead of dressing up a guess as policy.

Chronic wasting disease has been a management worry in parts of the southern Lower Peninsula for years, so a pilot built around antlerless harvest lands right in the middle of that. Fewer does on the ground generally means less deer-to-deer contact, and that matters most where CWD has turned up. The DNR frames the pilot as a hunter opportunity and a density study, not a CWD program. Still, the two goals aren’t in tension. If you want the fuller CWD picture across the southern Lower Peninsula, we’ve laid it out county by county in our chronic wasting disease guide for Michigan hunting land.

What This Does to Land Value in the Five Pilot Counties

Green food plot beside autumn hardwoods with an elevated box blind and a grassy two-track trail at sunsetHere’s the part that takes understanding land, not just regulations, to say plainly: doe-productive habitat just became the scarce asset in five specific Michigan counties.

Picture two nearly identical 80-acre parcels, one in Hillsdale, one twenty minutes away in Lenawee. Same cover ratio, same ag edge, same road frontage. Starting in 2027, the Hillsdale parcel can produce two bucks for the right hunter. The Lenawee parcel, sitting in a control county, produces one. That’s not a cosmetic difference. That’s the kind of gap that shows up in what a serious hunting-land buyer is willing to pay.

The features that actually drive antlerless productivity haven’t changed, but they matter more now: standing food sources and rotated food plots, cover diversity that holds does through pressure, reliable water, and low hunting pressure that lets a property carry deer instead of just passing them through.

Managed Michigan hunting properties already command a 15–30% premium over comparable unmanaged ground. Expect that gap to widen inside the five pilot counties as EASB eligibility becomes a real, marketable feature of the land itself.

This part is worth spelling out if you’re weighing a tillable-versus-hunting-land decision on the same property. A field left in row crop generates cash rent, but it doesn’t build antlerless carrying capacity. A field converted to a rotated food plot program, or left standing into winter, does both jobs at once in a pilot county, with rental-adjacent income potential and EASB eligibility working off the same acres.

We go deeper on that trade-off in our tillable land versus hunting land comparison.

How EASB Interacts With the 2027 One-Buck Rule

Mature white-tailed buck standing among oak trees and fallen leaves in morning mistThis is the part that makes 2027 the most consequential season Michigan hunting land has seen in years. The same year EASB opens in five counties, the Lower Peninsula’s new one-buck rule takes effect everywhere else. Most LP hunters get exactly one buck tag’s worth of opportunity. Hunters and landowners in the five pilot counties get a release valve: do the antlerless work, and a second buck is back on the table.

That combination stacks two 2027 rule changes directly on top of five specific counties. If you’re deciding where to buy hunting ground in Michigan this year, that stack is not a footnote. It’s close to the whole story. For the broader picture of everything shifting in 2026 and 2027, our complete guide to Michigan’s deer regulation changes walks through every rule in one place.

Think about what that means for a father-and-kid hunting operation, or a group camp splitting tags among four or five hunters. Under a flat one-buck rule, that camp’s total buck harvest drops hard compared to years past. Put that same camp on a well-managed Hillsdale County property and the antlerless work one or two members put in early season can put a second buck tag back on the table for the group. The pilot doesn’t just affect an individual hunter’s opportunity. It changes the math for anyone hunting property as a group.

What Landowners in the Pilot Counties Should Do Now

You don’t have to wait until 2027 to start positioning a property for what’s coming. A few things are worth doing this fall and winter:

  • Build antlerless carrying capacity now: food plot rotations, standing bean or corn left for winter, water access that holds deer through pressure.
  • Start documenting. Trail camera archives, harvest records, and dated habitat work all build a paper trail that means something to a buyer later.
  • If you’re planning to sell, the math is simple: a seller who starts documenting this winter has most of a year of evidence in hand by the time the 2027 season opens. For pricing and the brokerage-versus-cash math, see what sellers actually net on Michigan hunting land.
  • If you’re buying, recognize that pilot-county properties are, right now, still priced on 2026 fundamentals. The market hasn’t fully caught up to what 2027 changes.For sellers specifically, that documentation isn’t just goodwill. It’s a negotiating tool. A listing that can show three years of trail camera data, a mapped food plot rotation, and antlerless harvest history gives a buyer’s agent something concrete to point to instead of asking them to take your word for it. For buyers, the flip side is just as real: two properties in Hillsdale County can look identical in photos and be worlds apart in what they’ll actually produce once EASB opens, and the only way to tell the difference is to ask for exactly that kind of documentation before you make an offer.

That last point is the one we’d tell a buyer sitting across the truck tailgate from us: the window between today and next fall is exactly when a Hillsdale or Barry County property gets bought at a price that doesn’t yet reflect the second-buck upside.

FAQs Michigan's Earn-a-Second-Buck Pilot

What is the earn-a-second-buck rule in Michigan?

It’s a five-year pilot that lets hunters who harvest and report an antlerless deer in one of five Lower Peninsula counties buy a second tag for a buck with at least four points on one side. It’s authorized under WCO Amendment No. 7 of 2026 and begins with the 2027–28 season.

Which Michigan counties are in the second buck pilot program?

Barry, Hillsdale, Ingham, Kalamazoo and Lapeer. Each is paired with a control county (Allegan, Lenawee, Isabella, Washtenaw and Livingston, respectively) that does not get EASB eligibility.

When does Michigan’s earn-a-second-buck program start?

With the 2027–28 deer season. WCO Amendment No. 7 was issued on August 12, 2026, and its EASB rules take effect March 1, 2027. No hunter can earn a second buck during the 2026 seasons.

How much does a Michigan bonus buck tag cost?

It’s a two-step cost. First, the earn-a-second-buck license package: $40 for residents and nonresidents, $28 for senior residents. After you harvest and report an antlerless deer in a pilot county, the bonus buck tag is $20 for residents and $170 for nonresidents. The NRC approved these prices in August 2026; confirm them when the DNR publishes 2027 license fees.

Do I have to shoot a doe before I can get a second buck in Michigan?

Yes. You have to harvest and report an antlerless deer inside one of the five pilot counties first. That reported harvest is what makes you eligible to buy the bonus buck tag, and the tag is valid only in the pilot counties.

Is the earn-a-second-buck rule final or still proposed?

It’s final. The Natural Resources Commission approved the concept on May 13, 2026, and WCO Amendment No. 7 was issued on August 12, 2026. It’s a five-year pilot that sunsets on January 2, 2032.

The Window Is Open Right Now

The 2027 season is about a year out. The properties that will benefit most from this pilot are not. They’re on the market today, priced on fundamentals that haven’t caught up yet. If you’re weighing ground in Barry, Hillsdale, Ingham, Kalamazoo, or Lapeer County, that gap is worth understanding before someone else closes it first.

See current hunting land listings in the pilot counties, or reach out to a Michigan Whitetail Properties broker who’s already walked this ground.